Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Soybeans and Shoulder Harnesses

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Soybeans and Shoulder Harnesses

    Had a close call and one that pilots dread last Friday evening. I had an emergency landing. We were lucky enough to walk away unscratched! An FAA investigation is currently underway, but the preliminary investigation shows a pc of the leading edge may have departed from the prop inflight. The irony of this whole situation is that I was introducing a 15year old neighbor kid to flying and spent most of the 1 hr flight reinforcing safety and safe flying. We had just aborted a landing at a friend’s grass strip as I was not comfortable with a 50’ wide runway with 9’ corn flanking both sides. I had trimmed the plane for a gentle climb (about 75mph) as it was hot and I was watching oil temp closely. At about 1 1/2miles south of the grass strip and at about 800-1000AGL, the engine instantly started shaking so violently, that I thought it would depart the airframe. I immediately throttled back to idle and the vibration while still extensive was “tolerable”. Less than 30 seconds before this happened, I had just explained the dangers of low level flying and we had both tightened up our harnesses. As some of you know the pre-wars with the flap lever down below your knees is not accessible with the harness snug. You have to leave the shoulder harness loose until you are finished trimming. I calmly told Sam that we were going to make an emergency landing and explained that we were going for a bean field that was 1/4mile east. I had to instantly slip off 300-400’ to make the field. The bean field although far less than ideal was the best of (3) very poor landing choices….my other options were a half mile long flat wheat field full of 1500# round bales and a 20 degree side hill with a tractor mowing dead center. I dropped in over the beans and held the plane off as long as possible. At about 10ft off the deck, what I thought was an irrigation ditch came into view perpendicular and directly ahead less than 200ft away. If I remember anything, it was the fear of slamming into the ditch perpendicular to our travel. I gunned the engine( I had left it idling as I wanted some power if needed at landing) for a few second to gain another 20ft or so. As soon as I knew I could get past the ditch I started the nose back down but I had lost enough airspeed that I stalled at about 20-30ft. We came down real fast and from contact with the beans to full stop was less than 40 feet! The plane basically landed nose and LH gear first then cartwheeled up on the RH wingtip. We teetered on the nose for a second or two and then dropped back on the tail in an upright position. As soon as we stopped, I hit the mags and we bailed out my door. We were shaken but completely unscathed. The good Lord and good training were on my side this time!
    As pilots, we always wonder how we will react in this situation. I have told myself a hundred times to try to stay calm and fly the plane down if this ever happened to me……that is exactly what I did. In hindsight, I shocked myself at how calm I actually did stay during the descent. The plane is totaled but can be rebuilt…..my old bones are another story.
    Attached Files
    MIKE CUSHWAY
    1938 BF50 NC20407
    1940 BC NC27599
    TF#733

  • #2
    Re: Soybeans and Shoulder Harnesses

    Mike glad the two of you are ok the plane as you said can be fixed I have a good left tapered axle landing gear that i would sell that is a start Chuck
    1940 BLT/BC65 N26658 SER#2000

    Comment


    • #3
      Re: Soybeans and Shoulder Harnesses

      Mike,

      You did everything you could to have a safe outcome. I'm hoping you'll be working on her rebuild soon. If you need some motivation, please let me know if I can be of any help.
      Mike
      NC29624
      1940 BC65

      Comment


      • #4
        Re: Soybeans and Shoulder Harnesses

        Sounds like you learned well. You can always buy another or fix this one but injury or worse was not an option. George
        TF# 702 Don't be afraid to try something new. Remember amatuers built the ark, professionals built the titanic!

        Comment


        • #5
          Re: Soybeans and Shoulder Harnesses

          Mike,
          Thank God you are all right. Just don't think I could take loosing you and Josh in the same week. Great job on staying calm. We can always have a panic attack AFTER we are down and have departed the plane.
          My first cross county flight I had an engine failure. I was lucky, time in sailplanes and ignorance protected me from panic. I was just a passenger but was actually flying the plane smoother than the pilot while he tried to figure out where we were (you got it, we were lost when it happened!). I was cool and calm the whole way down under partial power. I told the pilot that I sure hoped the insurance companies plane came through the landing OK. He looked surprised and asked "aren't you scared?" I said I would wait to get scared till the trees were higher than we were. It broke the ice and we stayed calm the rest of the way down. We actually made it to a runway and the engine stopped on the roll out.
          The key seems to be, STAY CALM and live!
          Hank

          Comment


          • #6
            Re: Soybeans and Shoulder Harnesses

            Glad to hear everything worked out alright, Mike.
            Cheers,
            Marty


            TF #596
            1946 BC-12D N95258
            Former owner of:
            1946 BC-12D/N95275
            1943 L-2B/N3113S

            Comment


            • #7
              Re: Soybeans and Shoulder Harnesses

              Thank God you made it..... This has been quite a week. Two are returning here from AirVenture, hope they are okay. thanks for the good report . again you said it well , the ship can be fixed and you will mend. How did the 15 year okldd take it and his folks. ?
              Taylorcraft Foundation, Inc
              Forrest A Barber 330-495-5447
              TF#1
              www.BarberAircraft.com
              [email protected]

              Comment


              • #8
                Re: Soybeans and Shoulder Harnesses

                Damn Mike, I'm sure sorry to hear about that, but glad you were both ok!!!
                I'm so far behind, I think I'm ahead

                Comment


                • #9
                  Re: Soybeans and Shoulder Harnesses

                  Mike, glad to hear you two are okay!

                  Planes are replaceable, but people are not.
                  N69V (Formerly NC36462)
                  1941
                  BL12-65

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Re: Soybeans and Shoulder Harnesses

                    Good ol' soybeans.
                    Glad you are ok, Mike. Thanks for the studied information on the incident. Good information for the rest of us. Heal well that which may need it.
                    Steve
                    NC96855
                    Some assembly required

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Re: Soybeans and Shoulder Harnesses

                      A few pix of the props leading edge(or lack of).
                      Attached Files
                      MIKE CUSHWAY
                      1938 BF50 NC20407
                      1940 BC NC27599
                      TF#733

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Re: Soybeans and Shoulder Harnesses

                        Well, there but for the Grace of God go the rest of us. I'm still awaiting my turn to these events, but thus far I have so avoided them.

                        I hope I'm never put in a position to make the same decision, Mike, but you did well.

                        Remember: FLY THE AEOPLANE, and you did it, right up to the crash (attributed to Bob Hoover, methinks).

                        Lawyer speak: get your insurance company to get damages from the prop overhauler.

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          Re: Soybeans and Shoulder Harnesses

                          Crash sounds so.....messy
                          It should be refered to as "Mike's arrival to the bean field". Glad you are okay.....I had my turn 18 yrs ago when my engine failed on takeoff from a small grass strip. One of my wings folded back at the strut atttach......my son (who was 3 then), and I got away unscathed....I remember him asking "why did we land here daddy?" I remember when we hit the trees they (the trees) set us down to the ground as if we had been caught like a fly ball.

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            Re: Soybeans and Shoulder Harnesses

                            So glad your OK! So glad the bean field was there! I often look around, constantly looking for a field in case the BC12D quits. I should install a harness(s) as I think they can save your life! Takeoff is when I really get nervous, thinking to myself, "Sh--! this thing is almost as old as I am! And YES!....Mikes arrival (or "visit") in the bean field is PERFECT! JC

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              Re: Soybeans and Shoulder Harnesses

                              If available most times corn fields are a better choice. We had a guy land in a corn field at night, did very little damage.
                              TF# 702 Don't be afraid to try something new. Remember amatuers built the ark, professionals built the titanic!

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X