Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Looking for drawings of the wood ribs

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • #16
    Re: Looking for drawings of the wood ribs

    Originally posted by Hank Jarrett View Post
    OK, hope you are sitting down. A full stamped aluminum rib (all three sections with rivets and all) weighs in at 280 GRAMS! That is just about 10 ounces. If someone can make a wood rib that light, I'm not sure I would want to fly under it.
    Who has the actual weight of a wood one and a metal "stick" rib?
    Hank
    FWIW here are some L-2 rib weights...
    1. Metal truss type = 232 grams
    2. Wood - old, origin unknown = 283 grams
    3. Wood - old, w/ TAC insp stamp = 277 grams
    4. Wood - new, built by me = 306 grams


    The metal rib did not include it's companion false nose rib. My new ribs use 1/4x3/8" verticals instead of 1/4x1/4" and the small lightening hole in the nose piece is a slightly smaller diameter (~1/4"). There's also no varnish as yet but then the old ribs are dried out and varnish is pretty much gone.

    To keep it simple let's say the truss ribs are ~2 oz. lighter than the original wood ribs and my new ribs are ~1 oz. heavier than the original wood. With 15 ribs per wing my new ribs will be ~3 pounds heavier per wing than the truss-type metal ribs. There will be other differences in the weight of the spars and the leading and trailing edge coverings.

    Another observation... seeing the metal and wood ribs stacked together it's interesting to note that the diagonal members go to opposite corners. They both avoid the drag wires. Things were surprisingly well thought out back then so I wonder why the difference. Nothing jumps out.
    Attached Files
    Regards,
    Greg Young
    1950 Navion N5221K
    2021 RV-6 N6GY
    1940 Rearwin Cloudster in progress
    4 L-2 projects on deck (YO-57, TG-6 conv, L-2A, L-2B)
    Former Owner 1946 BC-12D's N43109 & N96282
    www.bentwing.com

    Comment


    • #17
      Re: Looking for drawings of the wood ribs

      Sounds like the different wing weights are about a Mud Dauber nest weight difference!
      Hank

      Maybe a Dauber nest plus a mouse nest between the heaviest and lightest.

      Comment


      • #18
        Re: Looking for drawings of the wood ribs

        Yeah, certainly not as much as I thought. I could have more impact with a few more salads and a few less fries.
        Regards,
        Greg Young
        1950 Navion N5221K
        2021 RV-6 N6GY
        1940 Rearwin Cloudster in progress
        4 L-2 projects on deck (YO-57, TG-6 conv, L-2A, L-2B)
        Former Owner 1946 BC-12D's N43109 & N96282
        www.bentwing.com

        Comment


        • #19
          Re: Looking for drawings of the wood ribs

          thank you for the numbers i guess there is not much difference the truss ribs times 15 is 7lb 10.753oz the post war stamped rib times 15 9lb 4.1507 30 pre war truss ribs 15 lb 4.1506 oz not a lot
          1940 BLT/BC65 N26658 SER#2000

          Comment

          Working...
          X