Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Aircraft Loses Aileron

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Aircraft Loses Aileron

    Not a Taylorcraft but interesting all the same:

    This is how I remember the incident:
    After dispatching skydivers I dropped the landing gear and closed the door.
    Trimmed, prepared for and started the descent.
    Approximately half way into the green the aircraft started to shake uncontrollably and in a destructive manner.
    Came back on the power and pulled the nose up.
    Aircraft eventually stopped shaking (approximately 10+ seconds?) and fell to the left which I managed to correct with rudder as the yoke was jammed in the full left position. :shock:
    In hindsight I think the shaking stopped when the right aileron broke.
    Managed to stabilise the aircraft as in flying straight with rudder and much reduced vibration.
    Less than 100 mph she wanted to stall and there was not enough rudder control.
    Looked out both windows and realised I was in trouble and could not land the aircraft.
    The yoke was jammed in full left and both ailerons were pointing up at about 15 degrees with the right aileron dislodged and sitting proud inches below the wing. :shock:
    I had two big speed brakes.
    I would have left the aircraft at this stage had I been wearing my parachute.
    Called CT international and declared an emergency.
    Described nature of emergency and requested another frequency to chat and remove other aircraft from my scenario.
    Options were offered.
    At this stage I was heading out to sea and was too scared to turn.
    I came back to them after I managed to rudder inch the aircraft around from 270 to 170 to face Cape Town.
    All options considered I chose Cape Town for the best available emergency services.
    With the way the aircraft was behaving I never actually expected to make Cape Town but I was dealing with bite size chunks.
    I was not sure how far down the wing could drop before the rudder would not bring it back and I dreaded one of those thermic drop a wing scenarios.
    Cape Town initially cleared me to join the circuit! then corrected that with cleared to join long final 19 with all aircraft cleared in the area.
    I declined a request for me to land 16 as wind was 18 and I wanted no crosswind component.
    Manipulated rudder, throttle and trim tab to set course for Cape Town - cleared for straight in approach 19 with full emergency services on standby.
    Decided not to use yoke or elevator in case it dislodged/ broke anything else.
    At about 10 miles I practiced/ simulated the landing a few times before arrival so I knew what to expect.
    The yoke locked in a full left position was a constant reminder that this was going to end badly.
    Tightened seat belt and decided not to open door at the risk of disturbing flight path.
    Transfer to tower 118.1 and they confirmed clear to land, all emergency services on standby and wished me good luck.
    Upon request the tower confirmed fire truck at intersection charlie, so told them I would land there.
    100 mph, over runway, rt rudder to bring left wing up, left rudder for center line and dropped power at the same time.
    Used yoke to help flare as speed bled off at the end.
    Greaser landing and stopped next to the fire truck. :shock:
    Taxi through main apron to maintenance hangars and took these photos... :shock:
    We never go anywhere near VNE.
    We descend at top of green.
    There must be a stronger word than FLUTTER!
    Attached Files

  • #2
    Re: Aircraft Loses Aileron

    Kind of like time a jumper got pulled through the right rear door post on our 182 jump ship. Deployment of chute, big round, inside cabin, whewww , I was not using my chute as a cushion and have always worn it since. Again full aileron, lots of rudder, around airport for a while , sorted it out.
    Sod field, emergency eqipment was a four wheeler with BIG fire bottle and three other guys with one stretcher..... worked out fine , touched around 80 mph , stopped , rode to office, showered, changed shorts , flew two more lifts in the other 182..... Jumper had a real stiff neck & back for a while, plus abrasions.
    Taylorcraft Foundation, Inc
    Forrest A Barber 330-495-5447
    TF#1
    www.BarberAircraft.com
    [email protected]

    Comment


    • #3
      Re: Aircraft Loses Aileron

      Have you found what caused the aileron to fail?
      Buell Powell TF#476
      1941 BC12-65 NC29748
      1946 Fairchild 24 NC81330

      Comment


      • #4
        Re: Aircraft Loses Aileron

        You might start with review of those unusual repairs on the LH aileron skin near the trailing edge. Perhaps ailerons out of balance due to improper maintenance?

        What is the airplane model? Is this a Cessna U206?
        Terry Bowden, formerly TF # 351
        CERTIFIED AERONAUTICAL PRODUCTS, LLC
        Consultant D.E.R. Powerplant inst'l & Engines
        Vintage D.E.R. Structures, Electrical, & Mechanical Systems
        BC12D, s/n 7898, N95598
        weblog: Barnstmr's Random Aeronautics
        [email protected]

        Comment


        • #5
          Re: Aircraft Loses Aileron

          What type of aircraft was used?

          Comment


          • #6
            Re: Aircraft Loses Aileron

            Originally posted by barnstmr View Post
            What is the airplane model? Is this a Cessna U206?
            Sounds like an older 210, as he says, "After dispatching skydivers I dropped the landing gear and closed the door."

            We used to jump an old, strutted 210....long ago... thought we were really hot stuff when we got the twin Beech!
            At any rate....sounds like it was a helluva ride!! Glad you are around to tell us about it!
            I'm so far behind, I think I'm ahead

            Comment


            • #7
              Re: Aircraft Loses Aileron

              Hi Guys,

              Follow the discussion on this incident at AVCOM a South African aviation Forum. You will have to register (it's quick and easy). The URL is


              Regards,
              Charles

              Comment


              • #8
                Re: Aircraft Loses Aileron

                I met a girl back in 75 that while acting a jumpmaster for a student had her reserve (chest mounted) opened by the student (he was reaching up to grab something to get ready in the door). Ripped off the whole right side from the door to the right elevator (cessena 172) the pilot licked the student out, he was on static line and he followed, she had been pulled out by her chute.
                She had a scar from her right side of head to her right ankle you wouldn't believe--and it didn't do a damn thing to her personality or how she handled herself- might have even made her wilder, man could she party.

                Comment


                • #9
                  Re: Aircraft Loses Aileron

                  I think I met her at a boogie on the East coast.... I noticed she had the scar and a toe ring ( she stepped on my tongue as I was crawling to my sleeping bag).
                  Taylorcraft Foundation, Inc
                  Forrest A Barber 330-495-5447
                  TF#1
                  www.BarberAircraft.com
                  [email protected]

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Re: Aircraft Loses Aileron

                    Hi Guys,

                    Chance shot of the C210 on Final, check the skew right aileron.

                    Regards,
                    Charles
                    Attached Files

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Re: Aircraft Loses Aileron

                      THat is great, chance shots are neat. Good thing it was not the "last" one of the ship and Pilot .
                      Does any one have the lastest on Kyle & Amanda Franklin OR the Twin Otter that went in having the engines tested. ???
                      Taylorcraft Foundation, Inc
                      Forrest A Barber 330-495-5447
                      TF#1
                      www.BarberAircraft.com
                      [email protected]

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Re: Aircraft Loses Aileron

                        according to the email I received yesterday he is OK and although she was much worse will recover too. L
                        "I'm from the FAA and we're not happy, until your not happy."

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          Re: Aircraft Loses Aileron

                          just got this from the Pietenpol list I believe it was an update Kyle posted to facebook....



                          I know you all have been waiting for an update, sorry for the delay. I was discharged on Monday and am now playing catch up on things. It's all getting a little overwhelming.

                          Amanda is doing well for the most part. She had a surgery yesterday. They worked on some more of her burned areas and unfortunately had to take down her left hand pinky, so now all she has left is her left thumb. They also went back in and re-set a bone fracture on her right eye to hopefully avoid her having double vision. I am praying that her vision remains just as good as it was before. �She has already lost her fingers the last thing I want is her vision to be compromised.�

                          Today was a big day. They gave her a shower, rotated her more vertical again and even sat her in a chair of some sort. A lot for one day. She is now resting comfortably and is slated for another surgery on Friday. I feel so sorry for her having to go through all this, it's just not right.

                          Thank you all again, I'll let you know when I have more.

                          Kyle
                          A&P/IA
                          Commercial ASEL/Instrument
                          N96999 '46 Taylorcraft BC-12D
                          N91467 Corvair Pietenpol
                          TF#1110 prev TF # 16

                          http://vansflyingservices.com

                          Comment

                          Working...
                          X